While the bustling food scenes in America’s major cities often steal the spotlight, there are hidden gems that offer an exceptional dining experience away from the crowds. These underrated restaurants may not have the flashiest exteriors or the most famous names, but they serve up unforgettable meals that will leave you coming back for more. Here are three hidden gems in major US cities that are worth seeking out.
1. The Broken Shaker – Miami, Florida
Nestled inside the Freehand Hotel in Miami’s Mid-Beach neighborhood, The Broken Shaker is a cozy, laid-back bar and restaurant that serves up creative cocktails and delicious small plates. While it may not be immediately obvious to first-time visitors, this hidden gem is a favorite among locals who are in the know. The charming, eclectic space has a retro vibe, with mismatched furniture, twinkling lights, and a relaxed atmosphere that makes you feel right at home.
The food menu at The Broken Shaker is simple but elevated, offering dishes like crispy chicken wings, tuna tartare, and roasted beets with goat cheese. Their small plates are perfect for sharing, and each dish is packed with fresh, seasonal ingredients. The drink menu is equally impressive, featuring unique cocktails made with craft spirits, herbs, and spices grown in their own garden. If you’re looking for a low-key spot to enjoy innovative drinks and flavorful food in Miami, The Broken Shaker is a must-try hidden gem.
2. The Walrus and the Carpenter – Seattle, Washington
Tucked away in the Ballard neighborhood of Seattle, The Walrus and the Carpenter is a small, unassuming oyster bar that offers one of the best seafood experiences in the city. While Seattle is famous for its seafood, this spot stands out for its dedication to serving only the freshest, highest-quality oysters, sourced from local waters along the Pacific Northwest coast. The intimate setting, with its rustic decor and cozy ambiance, creates a welcoming atmosphere for diners seeking an authentic taste of the sea.
Their selection of oysters is the star of the show, with options that change daily based on availability, but the clam chowder and grilled oysters are also worth ordering. For those not craving oysters, the smoked salmon and salted duck eggs are popular choices that showcase the region’s fantastic seafood and local produce. With its excellent service and intimate vibe, The Walrus and the Carpenter offers a true taste of Seattle’s thriving seafood scene, away from the tourist crowds.
3. Revolutionary Soup – Charlottesville, Virginia
For a warm, comforting meal in Charlottesville, Virginia, Revolutionary Soup is a hidden gem that locals rave about. Located on the corner of the historic downtown mall, this cozy, no-frills eatery specializes in fresh soups, salads, and sandwiches that are as healthy as they are delicious. The menu changes daily, depending on the season, with everything made from scratch using locally sourced ingredients. The focus is on wholesome, vibrant dishes that cater to a variety of dietary preferences, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.
The Tomato Basil Soup, paired with a grilled cheese sandwich, is a classic, but the menu also features inventive options like butternut squash soup with a touch of curry and hearty lentil stews. Their fresh salads, made with seasonal greens and topped with house-made dressings, are also a hit. For those seeking a quick, casual meal that is both satisfying and nourishing, Revolutionary Soup offers an ideal stop, providing exceptional comfort food that reflects the best of local ingredients and culinary creativity.